Reg Hardware

Asus Eee PC 900 flips one at MacBook Air with multi-touch input

Giles Jones

Pad too small 

The touchpad will be too small to make multitouch comfortable.

The eeepc 900 pad is probably the size of a standard laptop touchpad. When Apple added multitouch they increased the size of the touchpad.

Anonymous Coward

Mmm lawsuit... 

I'm sure Apple will have already patented this technology and could easily sue them. I know if MS had owned the patent they'd sue Asus into liquidation.

pete

regression? 

Boffin

"It also adds two-finger scrolling."

Erm... the multitouch macs don't have this? It's been working on my (old) MBP since time immemorial, can't believe they'd remove something so useful...

Tony Chandler

re: Mmm lawsuit... 

I was thinking this too. Seeing as every time Apple make a product which includes pretty much anything someone somewhere comes out of the woodwork to claim Apple nicked the idea off of them, then surely this is Apple's moment to return the favour?

Anonymous Coward

@mmm lawsuit 

concidering the size ofasus i wouldnt be surprised if theyed licensed the use of multi-touch from apple, its not like the eepc is in direct competiton with any of apples offerings

John Bayly

Re: Mmm lawsuit... 

Thumb Down

But multi-touch input has been around for a while, presented by Jeff Han at Adobe TED:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UcKqyn-gUbY

Although with the state of the USPTO I suppose Apple could have patented the Zoom & Scroll gestures for specific use with a touch pad on a sub 14" laptop.

Hopefully it would be classed as prior art and Asus could tell Apple f@ck off.

Anonymous Coward

RE Lawsuit 

Jobs Horns

Contrary to what you might think, Apple DID NOT invent multi touch technology. I can't remember the last thing crapple actually invented, they merely take other peoples products (and in some cases outright steal them) and integrate it into their own and then go on a marketing spree telling everyone how great they are. Multi touch was researched heavily by a company called fingerworks. Also there were at least 2 proof of concept phones designed BEFORE the iphoney

http://www.engadgetmobile.com/2006/10/08/nokias-aeon-full-surface-screen-cellphone-concept/

http://gizmodo.com/gadgets/cellphones/benqsiemens-black-box-concept-phone-204284.php

You can't patent something that has clear eveidence of prior art.

Paul

re: Mmm Lawsuit... 

Given that microsoft have been demoing multitouch devices I doubt apple hold that strong a patent on using multitouch?

Stuart Crook

Yeah, an Apple fanboi's nitpick... 

The two-finger scrolling -- horizontal as well as vertical -- has been around on Mac laptops for a few years, at least since the iBook G4 launched in 2005. (Also, two fingers + single button = right click, but nobody seems to want to steal that one.)

Steve

Pad's just fine 

My first and second fingers can just reach opposite corners of the touchpad on my current laptop. If the pad were any larger, I'd have to use two hands or odd combinations of 1st/3rd or 1st/4th fingers to use the full range of zoom.

Nick Palmer

@Mmm lawsuit... 

Stop

Gesture controls weren't *gasp* invented by Apple, so I doubt there'll be any such lawsuits in the offing. Indeed, any patent'd have to pass the "non-obvious" test, so given that Asus, Synaptics, ART, Dell, Interlink (they actually have a patent for a gesture-based touchpad control for a home entertainment system from 6 years ago) have all worked on this idea (and others besides), it fails explicitly on prior art grounds, and implicitly on the "non-obvious" test.

robert

cant wait for one of these 

had one of the original ones back in November but sent it back as it broke, ended up with a refund as they couldn'd find me a replacement. Picked up a 11" Vaio TZ in Japan in December which, although a whole different ball game to the eee, has been good. Problem is im scared to take it places my car might get broken into etc. So gonna get one of these new eee's.

DrXym

The screen is the biggest pain in the 700 

The EEE PC is a great device but the screen is too small. Bumping the size and resolution would make the device the perfect laptop for on the go, assuming the price doesn't go silly and leap into conventional laptop land.

The touchpad is actually okay on the 700. It already has a scroll wheel function but its down one edge. Run your finger down the edge and it acts like a scroll wheel. Hold ctrl while doing this and you zoom. It works fairly well but it runs afoul of the window you are open on some occasions. For example, if you have a browser window open but your cursor is over a flash animation (which usually have their own window), scrolling won't work. You have to move the cursor onto other content and then it works.

Peter Gathercole

Screen res? 

Is it really 1024x768? This is not a wide screen resolution, but one often used for 4x3 aspect laptop screens. If you were to keep the same aspect ratio, it would be 1024x614. 1280x660 would also be about right.

James Pickett

Excellent 

Paris Hilton

A two-finger gesture to Apple then! I'm not with this Holy Grail of thinness, which in the case of the Air looks like a recipe for cracked screens and buckled housings. I bought a new mobile phone recently, and went for a simple, rugged Nokia 3100, which is as small and thin as I want to go. The thin phones are harder to hold, more fragile and have less battery life, so what's the point?

Paris, because she'd buy an Air...

madra

oh no! 

Jobs Horns

wow! - asus have dealt apple a body-blow with this:

'our vapourware will feature something your actual hardware already has'

apple must be reeling from the news!

Anonymous Coward

Pad looks ok 

Thumb Up

in that pic the pad looks to be almost 1/3rd of the width of the pc itself, im sure this will be fine for the many, of course those with fat finger syndrome may need special equipment. now where are those fingfinners.. (made from Hubert Farnsworths finglongers and a pencil sharpener..)

Anyway whats with 'will be' then 'is probably' is that just hopefull thinking? someone just wasted there money on a jobbo job?

Simon Oxlade

Touchpad is bigger ... a bit 

Thumb Up

Touchpad seems to be a little bit bigger than my model 701. Looks like it now fills the case depression in the 'wrist-rest' area in front of the keyboard - so it's about 10mm wider and possibly (it's hard to tell) 2-3mm deeper. The case depression itself doesn't appear to be any bigger...

However I'm not entirely sure the touchpad is quite big enough for gesture input - not for my fat fingers anyway. Wait and see...

Shame they're moving to a 'dope on a rope' style power supply. Standout feature for me on the 701 was the convertible powersupply (US/UK) without the need to carry a seperate 'figure of 8' lead.

Screen size looks nice though, and they really should have included Bluetooth from the off. Can't wait to have a play with the new one...

Anonymous Coward

Battery 

Alert

All very nice, but have they improved the battery life? All this extra stuff will surely sap more juice, which is already more than the battery can handle. Two or three hours of surfing is all you really get, if that goes any lower it will make the thing useless.

Nick Palmer

@madra 

Paris Hilton

Yeah...errr..."vapourware"...that means it'd have to actually not exist, as opposed to being hardware supplied to the FCC for certification, wouldn't it? Considering that it's already there, working enough to be certified, and indeed features no more than functionality which has been incorporated into machines since well before the Air was even dreamed of, that'd be some pretty solid "vapour". Also, considering that this'll be a (small) fraction of the price of the Air, I'd say Asus FTW on this one...

PH for her prior art in gesture-based touch controls...

Anonymous Coward

Touch screen 

Why don't they just add the touchscreen mod? That would be the icing on the cake.

Ishkandar

two-finger zooming... 

Happy

I've been using two-finger zooming for more than 40 years !! Held vertically upwards and wriggled, it means zoom out (or "fxxx off"); held vertically downwards and pointed, it means zoom in (or "come here!") !!

Ralphe Neill

Oy! 

Unhappy

Where's the picture of the Eee PC user, then?

Anonymous Coward

re: RE Lawsuit @ AC 

Jobs Halo

you are correct about Fingerworks doing a lot of the initial research and development into multi-touch technology

and who owns Fingerworks now?

Uwe Dippel

Where is the 

white touch-pad on the beach, please?

Anonymous Coward

re: RE Lawsuit @ AC 

Jobs Horns

'who owns Fingerworks now?'

Like I said earlier

'I can't remember the last thing crapple actually invented, they merely take other peoples products (and in some cases outright steal them) and integrate it into their own and then go on a marketing spree telling everyone how great they are'

Point made. Isn't it funny how if MS buy a company to get hold of a technology they are automatically the 'evil corporation'. When Apple do it, everything's hunky-dory as they go about claiming they are so 'innovative'

Geoff Mackenzie

Scrolling 

Joke

Yep, I've been giving Apple two fingers for many years now.

Anonymous Coward

Twas under the impression.... 

Heart

That Asus made Apple Mac's anyway....

Anonymous Coward

Battery and adapter woes 

Stop

The really good thing about the Eee is the tiny adapter - so it and the machine don't weigh anything in your bag.

Now with a larger screen, where is the battery life going? It is already tentative, and what with bluetooth as well, you are going to need an adapter all the time, and if that is going to get heavier as well, then I think the Eee is losing some at least of its charm for me.

I am going to keep my money in my wallet for the moment - it is (im)perfectly usable at the moment as a travelling companion where you don't need a full-sized laptop, it doesn't need a larger screen if that threatens battery life and its tiny adapter.

rjstep3

Shinku

Typo? 

That'll be a resolution of 1024x600, right?