Once again sony screws over its costomers with crap new hardware, i used to realy like sony untill the PS3 came out but with the price of ps3 in the uk and now with the new dodgy psp sony can shove it all.
Tut tut Sony, standards are slipping. There may well be recompense for consumers in law, but only to get their money back. Sony should fix the problem and issue new for old consoles to registered purchasers. They won't though.
Scanlines were always a sign of a hi-res arcade screen back in the day.
If the screen is sharper and less flickery it doesn't surprise me that you can now see the lines between the pixels if you look *really* closely at still screens.
Are we sure this isn't just a VCOM issue on the LCD? #
Posted Wednesday 22nd October 2008 18:32 GMT
Many handheld DVD players have awful line-structure which appears to be the result of "row-inversion" LCDs where the common-electrode voltage (a.k.a. Vcom) has not been very well tweaked. Tweak that voltage (internal preset potentiometer or digital preset) and the problem largely goes away.
I haven't seen an affected PSP-3000, but the hypothesis can be tested if you apply a bitmap composed of alternate horizontal lines of black and RGB(180,180,180). If it's a row-inversion display and this pattern flickers like crazy then it confirms poor Vcom setting.
Plenty of desktop LCDs have a similar issue with scrolling cross-hatch patterns (they use different inversion patterns) showing on mid-level colours - I've opened several 17" monitors to tweak out the problem.
Sony used to have decent electronics, but seem to have lost their way the last 10-15 years and no idea what to do about it. Everything they turn out now is shite in one way or another (can you say bleuray?).
Anonymous Coward
It looks like the PSP output interlaced graphics #
Posted Wednesday 22nd October 2008 20:04 GMT
I've seen better screenshots of this problem and it looks very much like the result you get when you de-interlace an interlaced image and don't do anything to filter it.
With interlaced images you alternate between displaying the odd and even lines of an image with each frame drawn. For the PSP this means it has less work to do when rendering a scene, but it also means when you put a much better screen on the system the artefacts of de-interlacing are apparent.
Cheap ways to combat interlacing are to either blur the image or using line doubling to hide the lack of data from frame to frame. Neither of which creates a very nice image, but on the small PSP screen it could work. Higher end devices like projectors have much better de-interlacing chips which remove all artefacts and still give a sharp image. The only problem is that if you have a flickering sprite it won't flicker properly with this method. Plus it's expensive which is probably why Sony didn't do it.
Long story short, the PSP will always have this problem.
I would love to buy a PSP, but since Sony seems intent on destroying good ideas, good intentions, and their company image with bad designs, I think I will avoid the PSP.
I regret selling my Atari Lynx all those years ago. That device kicked ass!
And I'm perfectly happy with the screen so far. It's not a hideous artifacted mess, nor is it a massive improvement over the launch models. It *is* perfectly serviceable and displays the games nicely, including a variety of 2D and 3D titles.
But by all means let's carry on judging it from screen shots. That's a fine tradition in the world of gaming, after all.
I own Sony Vegas Pro 8.1 and the thing hangs when I import about 40 MP4 clips (about 1GB in total) from my HD camcorder in one go. Sony's advice - import in batches of 10 (which doesn't really solve the problem anyway) or convert all the clips to DV first! I can't believe no one at Sony thought to test this scenario. My PC's a new Intel Core2 Quad 2.83 and 4 GB RAM before anyone says get a faster machine. It is Vista crippled but that's only because I needed Vista for Vegas 64-bit!
No such thing with LCDs. It's a fixed pixel based display with pixel based refresh, not a CRT with electron beam scan lines that draws the display a line at a time!
More than that, LCDs are by their very nature progressive displays. Interlacing that may exist in the game's display would be de-interlaced. Though I can't believe they'd be using interlacing on games intended for a small LCD display.
However, the artefacts shown in those screenshots are more akin to what some observe on projectors, i.e. "chickenwire" effect. Usually a physical limitation.
Sounds more like they've just opted for a cheaper/poor quality LCD display.
As for Sony quality. Used to be a Sony fan, but since around 2000 their quality has dropped sharply in my opinion based on the failures I've had in Sony kit and from what I've read.
Sony powerless to fix PSP screen problem
steve
Sony messes up again #
Posted Wednesday 22nd October 2008 13:03 GMT
Once again sony screws over its costomers with crap new hardware, i used to realy like sony untill the PS3 came out but with the price of ps3 in the uk and now with the new dodgy psp sony can shove it all.
filey
Feature? #
Posted Wednesday 22nd October 2008 13:03 GMT
Usual cobblers about a fault being a feature, who'd have thought Sony people also worked at Microsoft too.
Iain
Didn't beta test #
Posted Wednesday 22nd October 2008 13:03 GMT
Tut tut Sony, standards are slipping. There may well be recompense for consumers in law, but only to get their money back. Sony should fix the problem and issue new for old consoles to registered purchasers. They won't though.
Anonymous Coward
Nintendo Dirty Tricks Campaign. #
Posted Wednesday 22nd October 2008 13:05 GMT
To fool dumb consumers that don't realise that a still image can't accurately portray what a moving image looks like.
Ever taken a picture of your TV screen? Clearly people are stupid if they believe this crap.
Anonymous Coward
@ "Nintendo Dirty Tricks Campaign" AC #
Posted Wednesday 22nd October 2008 15:37 GMT
You ARE Mark, and I claim my £5.
Daniel
Shame on you sony #
Posted Wednesday 22nd October 2008 15:37 GMT
And heres me planning to buy a new one... I think i'll stick with what i got... As they say Newer isn't always better.
Joe K
Peh #
Posted Wednesday 22nd October 2008 15:37 GMT
Scanlines were always a sign of a hi-res arcade screen back in the day.
If the screen is sharper and less flickery it doesn't surprise me that you can now see the lines between the pixels if you look *really* closely at still screens.
Sheesh.
Sir Runcible Spoon
@AC (12:21) #
Posted Wednesday 22nd October 2008 15:37 GMT
You really are a retard.
What part of
"“scan lines have come out to be more visible as a result of improving response time to alleviate the after images on PSP-3000”. " *Sony said*
didn't you read?
Rick
didn't beta test...sure they did #
Posted Wednesday 22nd October 2008 17:00 GMT
Just like all the electronics companies do now-a-days...they do widescale public beta test called putting it out to market. :P
Andrew Steer
Are we sure this isn't just a VCOM issue on the LCD? #
Posted Wednesday 22nd October 2008 18:32 GMT
Many handheld DVD players have awful line-structure which appears to be the result of "row-inversion" LCDs where the common-electrode voltage (a.k.a. Vcom) has not been very well tweaked. Tweak that voltage (internal preset potentiometer or digital preset) and the problem largely goes away.
I haven't seen an affected PSP-3000, but the hypothesis can be tested if you apply a bitmap composed of alternate horizontal lines of black and RGB(180,180,180). If it's a row-inversion display and this pattern flickers like crazy then it confirms poor Vcom setting.
Plenty of desktop LCDs have a similar issue with scrolling cross-hatch patterns (they use different inversion patterns) showing on mid-level colours - I've opened several 17" monitors to tweak out the problem.
Google search for
LCD flicker inversion
should give you some more pointers on this theme.
Anonymous Coward
sad day, really #
Posted Wednesday 22nd October 2008 20:04 GMT
Sony used to have decent electronics, but seem to have lost their way the last 10-15 years and no idea what to do about it. Everything they turn out now is shite in one way or another (can you say bleuray?).
Anonymous Coward
It looks like the PSP output interlaced graphics #
Posted Wednesday 22nd October 2008 20:04 GMT
I've seen better screenshots of this problem and it looks very much like the result you get when you de-interlace an interlaced image and don't do anything to filter it.
With interlaced images you alternate between displaying the odd and even lines of an image with each frame drawn. For the PSP this means it has less work to do when rendering a scene, but it also means when you put a much better screen on the system the artefacts of de-interlacing are apparent.
Cheap ways to combat interlacing are to either blur the image or using line doubling to hide the lack of data from frame to frame. Neither of which creates a very nice image, but on the small PSP screen it could work. Higher end devices like projectors have much better de-interlacing chips which remove all artefacts and still give a sharp image. The only problem is that if you have a flickering sprite it won't flicker properly with this method. Plus it's expensive which is probably why Sony didn't do it.
Long story short, the PSP will always have this problem.
Tristan Young
PSP-3000 #
Posted Thursday 23rd October 2008 07:59 GMT
I would love to buy a PSP, but since Sony seems intent on destroying good ideas, good intentions, and their company image with bad designs, I think I will avoid the PSP.
I regret selling my Atari Lynx all those years ago. That device kicked ass!
Adrian Jackson
I just bought a PSP-3000 #
Posted Thursday 23rd October 2008 11:41 GMT
And I'm perfectly happy with the screen so far. It's not a hideous artifacted mess, nor is it a massive improvement over the launch models. It *is* perfectly serviceable and displays the games nicely, including a variety of 2D and 3D titles.
But by all means let's carry on judging it from screen shots. That's a fine tradition in the world of gaming, after all.
Neil Docherty
Sony don't seem to test things these days! #
Posted Thursday 23rd October 2008 21:29 GMT
I own Sony Vegas Pro 8.1 and the thing hangs when I import about 40 MP4 clips (about 1GB in total) from my HD camcorder in one go. Sony's advice - import in batches of 10 (which doesn't really solve the problem anyway) or convert all the clips to DV first! I can't believe no one at Sony thought to test this scenario. My PC's a new Intel Core2 Quad 2.83 and 4 GB RAM before anyone says get a faster machine. It is Vista crippled but that's only because I needed Vista for Vegas 64-bit!
Anonymous Coward
Scan lines #
Posted Friday 24th October 2008 13:07 GMT
No such thing with LCDs. It's a fixed pixel based display with pixel based refresh, not a CRT with electron beam scan lines that draws the display a line at a time!
More than that, LCDs are by their very nature progressive displays. Interlacing that may exist in the game's display would be de-interlaced. Though I can't believe they'd be using interlacing on games intended for a small LCD display.
However, the artefacts shown in those screenshots are more akin to what some observe on projectors, i.e. "chickenwire" effect. Usually a physical limitation.
Sounds more like they've just opted for a cheaper/poor quality LCD display.
As for Sony quality. Used to be a Sony fan, but since around 2000 their quality has dropped sharply in my opinion based on the failures I've had in Sony kit and from what I've read.